Clones and dupes inspired by:
Alexandre.J Black Muscs (2012) is a bold citrus-floral that balances brisk freshness with a lush, powdery warmth, offering an unconventional, polarizing signature in modern perfumery.
The Sniff Test is independent and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, sponsored by, or approved by Alexandre.J. Brand and product names are used only to identify the fragrance being reviewed and compared. References to alternatives, impressions, clones, or similar products do not imply any connection with the original brand or rights holder.
Inspired-By Comparison
Every clone rated on similarity and performance. Oils and sprays are priced on separate lines, because a millilitre of oil is not a millilitre of spray.
Oil is undiluted, so a millilitre of oil holds several times more fragrance than a millilitre of spray. Each format is ranked on its own.
Each line shows one size: a 50ml spray (30ml, or the nearest size, when the vendor has no 50ml) and the oil closest to 10ml. Vendors also sell other sizes, including samples and bulk.
Prices are converted to your selected currency at recent exchange rates. Vendors bill in their own currency, so the amount you are charged may differ slightly.
Get an email when an alternative to Black Muscs drops in price or a new, better-rated match appears. No spam — alerts only.
You'll get alerts for this fragrance plus our occasional newsletter — unsubscribe from either in one click, anytime.
Rate them on similarity, strength, longevity, and sillage to help others find the best match.
Find the Original
Alexandre.J Black Muscs is the benchmark for this scent profile. Alternatives may be worth comparing, but they are independent products and we do not present them as equivalent to Alexandre.J's own fragrance.
They do not replace the original fragrance, its presentation, or the version created under the brand's own quality control. If that is what you are looking for, search the official site or trusted retailers below.
Alexandre.J
Official website VisitAmazon
Check price Shop
Sephora
USA Shop
Nordstrom
USA Shop
Notino
UK Shop
Perfume Direct
UK ShopAbout the Original
The fragrance these clones are inspired by.
Alexandre.J Black Muscs (2012) is a unisex release that sits among the house's musk-focused offerings, pairing a bright citrus opening with a rose-centered heart and a dense musky-amber base. Bergamot and lemon give a sharp, fresh lift that contrasts with a heart of rose, violet and a hint of patchouli, while musk and amber create a powdery, warm finish. The fragrance rates 3.76/5 from 474 votes, a sign of mixed but engaged reception: many wearers praise its bold rose-and-citrus character and creative profile, while others find the heavy musk or metallic facets off-putting.
Our take
I find Black Muscs interesting and uneven. The lemon and bergamot sharpen the rose in a way that can be bright and modern, and the musk-amber drydown has real presence. On me the base sometimes reads metallic or too powdery, and that turns the scent from appealing to harsh. Community votes show more people like or love it than dislike it, and the strong sillage and long longevity suit me when I want a bold, evening-leaning rose musk, but it is not subtle or safe.
Dominant Accords
The Bottle
Black Muscs has a bottle with a tall cylindrical form, rounded shoulders, and a domed black cap. Gold-coloured ribbing, crest-like ornament, hanging round side ornament, and a horizontal gold band make it lavish rather than restrained. The repeated wavy surface pattern adds visual interest, though the abundance of decoration may feel theatrical rather than elegant.
Original or Clone
The bottle gives Black Muscs a stronger case than its market evidence alone could provide. Four interpretations from two houses have taken this rose, citrus and musky fragrance as their model, making its standing as a reference clear. That does not prove anything about how closely those versions resemble it, but it does make the original the more defensible purchase for readers who want this particular Alexandre.J release and its ornate presentation.
Western Valley Avenue London
2 alternatives from £5.27
Narciso Rodriguez
7 alternatives from £3.99
Xerjoff
2 alternatives from £4.00
Kim Kardashian
3 alternatives from £5.27
Chanel
3 alternatives from £3.99
Creed
4 alternatives from £3.00
Arabian Oud
1 alternative from £3.00
Creed
2 alternatives from £5.99
Alexandre.J
3 alternatives from £4.00
Alexandre.J
4 alternatives from £3.99
Alexandre.J
1 alternative from £9.79
Alexandre.J
3 alternatives from £4.99
Alexandre.J
1 alternative from £10.55
Alexandre.J
1 alternative from £9.99
Alexandre.J
4 alternatives from £3.99
Alexandre.J
1 alternative from £8.98
Third-party product images on this page support product identification, navigation, comparison, commentary and review.
Fragrance brands pictured: .
Brand names identify the products pictured; they do not necessarily identify the copyright owner of a particular image. The Sniff Test does not claim ownership of third-party images. Rights may belong to the relevant brand, original photographer, agency, image library, licensor or another rights holder.
Individual uses are assessed under applicable UK copyright exceptions, including fair dealing for criticism or review and quotation where the statutory conditions are met.
Independent ratings
Real Prices, Updated Weekly
4 Listed Vendors
No Sponsored Results